PFAS packaging rules face industry pushback ahead of 2027
Members of the packaging and recycling industries have raised concerns over changes to the Recyclability Assessment Methodology (RAM), particularly the introduction of stricter requirements for packaging containing PFAS, commonly known as forever chemicals.
Updated by PackUK in July, the RAM 2027 guidance introduces an automatic red classification for packaging containing PFAS above specified thresholds. Under the Extended Producer Responsibility for packaging (pEPR) scheme, products given a red rating face the highest modulated fees.
The changes have prompted concerns across the industry, with trade bodies warning that the new criteria could have unintended consequences for recycling and the use of recycled materials.
Stricter criteria for packaging containing PFAS
The July update introduced several changes to the automatic red criteria, which identify packaging formats and materials considered difficult or unsuitable for recycling.
Under the revised guidance, packaging containing more than one part per million (ppm) of total PFAS will automatically receive a red rating. For food packaging, the threshold is considerably lower, at 25 parts per billion (ppb).
The updated criteria also cover packaging containing certain substances of concern above limits established under UK REACH legislation, alongside substances classified under other relevant chemical regulations.
Brian Lodge, Director of Plastics and Flexible Packaging at the British Plastics Federation, highlighted the significant change from the previous RAM guidance, which focused on intentionally added PFAS.
He explained that extending the criteria to all PFAS, regardless of how they enter packaging, was unexpected for many businesses and represents a stricter approach than the EU’s Packaging and Packaging Waste Regulation (PPWR).
Concerns over the impact on recycled materials
Although industry representatives recognise the importance of managing PFAS, questions have been raised about how the new requirements could affect the wider recycling system.
Recycled materials can contain trace levels of PFAS, creating concerns that packaging manufacturers could be discouraged from incorporating recycled content if it automatically results in a red classification.
Martin Kersh, CEO of the Packaging Federation, has questioned whether the unintended presence of PFAS should be enough to classify otherwise recyclable packaging as red, particularly without evidence that it affects the recycling process.
He warned that the approach could reduce demand for recycled materials, influence investment decisions and undermine efforts to increase recycled content.
The Federation argues that where specific PFAS substances genuinely affect recyclability, the guidance should identify the materials and processes involved rather than applying a blanket classification.
Questions over the role of RAM
Industry bodies have also questioned whether the RAM is the appropriate framework for regulating chemical substances.
Designed to assess the recyclability of packaging, the methodology does not necessarily establish whether the presence of a particular chemical prevents a material from being recycled.
Kersh has called for PackUK to demonstrate how the proposed thresholds relate to real recycling processes, rather than relying solely on chemical limits established through other regulatory frameworks.
Industry calls for a 12-month delay
The Packaging Federation and other industry organisations are calling for PackUK to postpone the proposed PFAS changes by 12 months.
The suggested delay would retain the previous RAM 1.1 wording, which focused on intentionally added PFAS, while allowing time for further technical investigation.
The Federation wants recyclers, reprocessors, packaging manufacturers and independent laboratories to work together to assess the impact of the new criteria and establish whether a broader approach is necessary.
The Confederation of Paper Industries (CPI) has also expressed support for maintaining the focus on intentionally added PFAS.
Dimitra Rappou, Executive Director of Sustainable Products at CPI, warned that applying broader PFAS thresholds across packaging could disproportionately affect recovered fibre.
She highlighted the risk that penalising recycled materials containing unintentionally present PFAS could encourage manufacturers to return to virgin fibre, potentially working against wider circular economy objectives.
CPI has also emphasised the importance of having sufficient laboratory capacity, reliable testing methods and realistic implementation timelines before introducing further changes.
Defra and PackUK respond
In response to industry concerns, Defra and PackUK have established a technical expert group to investigate the issue further.
A PackUK spokesperson confirmed that feedback from industry and the group’s findings will help inform the next steps, with an update expected in due course.
PackUK also encouraged businesses across the packaging value chain to contribute to discussions and help shape future developments.
With industry bodies continuing to call for a delay, the debate highlights the challenge of balancing chemical regulation with recyclability and the wider ambitions of a circular packaging economy.
Stay in the loop
Add us as a preferred source
One click, and posts like this show up more often when you search Google.
Check out our socials
The latest packaging projects

Innocent and Notpla gives ginger shots an edible packaging makeover
Luxury consumers are spending more carefully, regulation is intensifying, and brands are being challenged to deliver more with less. Yet Jane Hamilton, Senior Business Journalist at The Times, believes the desire for luxury remains remarkably resilient. Speaking at London Packaging Week, she argued that changing prestige economics could make packaging more important, not less.

The price of prestige: Why luxury’s squeeze could make packaging more important than ever
Luxury consumers are spending more carefully, regulation is intensifying, and brands are being challenged to deliver more with less. Yet Jane Hamilton, Senior Business Journalist at The Times, believes the desire for luxury remains remarkably resilient. Speaking at London Packaging Week, she argued that changing prestige economics could make packaging more important, not less.